Skip to main content

Comparison

Siding repair or replacement: which one do you need?

By All Purpose Anytime Services LLC

Repair when the damage is in one area and the wall behind is sound. Replace when it is failing everywhere or cannot be matched. Either way, the wall gets checked first.

Repair is enough when

  • The damage is in one place: a storm, an impact, a few loose or cracked panels
  • The sheathing and weather barrier behind it are dry and sound
  • The profile and colour can be matched closely enough for you

Replacement is the better money when

  • Panels are warped, cracked or loose on several sides of the house
  • The siding is faded and at the end of its life all over
  • Rot or water damage keeps turning up behind it
  • A partial repair would never match

The matching problem

Siding makers retire profiles, and the panels on your wall have been in the sun for years. On an older house the new piece can be a shade or a shape off. You hear that from us before paying for a repair, not after it is nailed up.

If the patch will show, the choice is between living with it, replacing one full elevation, or replacing the lot.

The wall decides more than the siding

Behind the panels sit the sheathing boards and a water resistant wrap, and on many houses a record of every leak the wall has had. When the old siding comes off and the wood is soft, work stops, you see it, and the repair is priced before anything covers it again.

New siding over a wet wall looks good for a year. Then the same problem comes back through it.

What changes the price

The size of the walls and the height of the house set the base. Any rotten sheathing found under the old panels adds to it. Vinyl, fibre cement and wood each cost differently to buy and to hang. On time, a typical house is a matter of days, and wet weeks stretch it more than anything else.

In St. Charles, Alexandria's BAR districts and DC historic districts, new siding may need approval before the permit. Check first.

Not sure which one?

We look at what is failing and whether it is the siding or what is behind it.